Stacy Stahl
Stacy Stahl is a Key West real estate broker, industry leader, and long-time Florida Keys resident with more than 20 years of experience in luxury residential and small commercial real estate. As Broker/Owner of Realty ONE Group Destination, Stacy is widely recognized for her deep local knowledge, strategic market insight, and high-touch service throughout Key West and the Florida Keys.
A Global Real Estate Advisor, Stacy works with buyers and sellers seeking primary residences, second homes, investment properties, and commercial opportunities across the Keys. Her approach blends data-driven pricing, thoughtful marketing, and discretion — making her a trusted advisor for both long-time locals and out-of-area clients navigating the unique Florida Keys market.
Trusted Leadership in Florida & National Real Estate
In addition to her brokerage work, Stacy is a respected voice in organized real estate. She has served on the Florida REALTORS® Board of Directors since 2016, representing real estate professionals statewide, and was appointed to the National Association of REALTORS®(NAR) Board of Directors in 2020. In these roles, she advocates for homeownership, property rights, ethical standards, and strong communities at both the state and national levels.
Her leadership and service have been recognized with numerous honors, including:
- REALTOR®of the Year (2018) – Key West Association of REALTOR®
- RPAC Hall of Fame Inductee (2023)
- Florida REALTOR®Honor Society
- Inaugural Class of Florida REALTORS®Board Certified Professionals
- Deep Roots in the Florida Keys Community
Originally from Northern New Jersey, Stacy’s connection to the Florida Keys began with a family vacation that changed the course of her life. Her parents eventually relocated permanently to Big Pine Key, and after an early career as a buyer for major department stores, Stacy felt the unmistakable pull of the islands and returned to make Key West home. Today, she and her family are firmly woven into the fabric of the community she serves.
Stacy is deeply involved in the cultural and charitable life of the Keys. She serves on the Board of Directors for the Waterfront Playhouse and A Positive Step Monroe County, supporting both the arts and critical community services. She previously served as President of the Mystick Krewe of Key West and was honored as the 2009 Duchess of Fantasy Fest, celebrating the creativity, inclusivity, and philanthropy that define Key West.
A Story-Driven, Client-Focused Approach to Real Estate
Passionate about storytelling in all its forms, Stacy believes real estate is more than a transaction — it’s about place, connection, and lifestyle. Whether guiding clients through a luxury home purchase, advising sellers on positioning their property in a competitive market, or advocating for the future of homeownership, Stacy brings clarity, integrity, and heart to every interaction.
For clients seeking an experienced Key West REALTOR®, Florida Keys broker, and luxury real estate advisor, Stacy Stahl offers a rare combination of market expertise, leadership experience, and genuine community connection.
